Indian motorcycle Roadmaster (2015–2019): what actually fails
The documented failure patterns on used Indian motorcycle Roadmasters — the mileage window where each shows up,
and what the repair typically costs at an independent shop. This is the same data NoLemon's Brief checks
against every VIN.
Exhaust overheating and rear-cylinder heat (recall 16V-446)
Recall 16V-446 addressed engine misfires that overheat the exhaust on 2014-2016 Thunder Stroke bikes, and the Roadmaster's full fairing and bags make its well-documented rear-cylinder heat even more noticeable. Idle it in place for ten minutes and judge for yourself. Verify the recall is closed before buying.
BEFORE YOU BUY Ask for repair records covering this item. If it hasn't been addressed and the
car is in or near the mileage window, price the up to $600 repair into your offer — or make it the seller's problem.
2015–2019TYPICAL 0k–60k MIUP TO $350
Gear position switch false neutral (recall 19V-776)
The Roadmaster is included in recall 19V-776: oxidized gear-position switch contacts make the dash show neutral while in gear, so the bike can start in gear or stall in traffic. Free dealer fix — run the VIN and confirm closure. Watch the gear indicator closely on the test ride.
BEFORE YOU BUY Ask for repair records covering this item. If it hasn't been addressed and the
car is in or near the mileage window, price the up to $350 repair into your offer — or make it the seller's problem.
Recall 15V-721 covers 2015-2016 Roadmasters: the rear brake master cylinder can lose pressure or fail entirely. Confirm the recall was performed and press the rear pedal hard during inspection — it should be firm with no fade. Check for fluid weeping around the rear reservoir.
BEFORE YOU BUY Ask for repair records covering this item. If it hasn't been addressed and the
car is in or near the mileage window, price the up to $400 repair into your offer — or make it the seller's problem.
Buying a used Roadmaster?
Run the VIN through NoLemon free — decode, open recalls, safety ratings and complaint counts in seconds.
The full Brief adds title & salvage history, market position, and a negotiation battle card with exact prices.
